Matia Kitchen 🍽️

What People Are Saying 💬

AI summary of real reviews

Customer Praise

• "Phenomenal experience" with an "incredibly inventive" menu that changes regularly.
• Customer service was praised as "impeccable," with staff being described as knowledgeable and friendly.
• A unique tasting experience with locally sourced greens and proteins featuring dishes like sunchokes and celery root.
• Guests felt welcomed and were treated with unexpected friendships by the restaurant team.

Atmosphere and Service

• The ambience is "relaxing with low light and quiet music" conducive to easy conversation.
• The atmosphere balances high-end dining with a "welcoming casual" feel, making it suitable for couples or small groups.
• Decor includes flowers and oil lamps on each table, contributing to a "casual but fresh and stylish" vibe.
• Spencer, a host, was adept at creating a calm environment even in the event of late arrivals.

Food Quality

• Localized ingredients take center stage, with praise for "stellar food largely from locally sourced ingredients."
• Unique dishes such as sunchokes and celery root impressed diners, reflecting Avery's passion in the kitchen.
• Wine selection was described as "very well selected, interesting, and delicious."
• However, some found the lounge menu items like "Clam Spaghetti and Lamb Ragu Pasta" to be overly salty, rendering the meal unpleasant.

Overall Experience

• The establishment is considered a "must eat when on Orcas Island," boasting a memorable dining experience.
• Some guests felt that despite the high prices, every penny was well spent for the quality received.
• The restaurant unexpectedly imposes an additional 4% surcharge labeled as "OPTIONAL," which some patrons found misleading.
• A desire to return was frequently expressed, with many guests planning future visits.