The Old Mill Restaurant 🏰

What People Are Saying 💬

AI summary of real reviews

Customer Praise

• "Food was fast, service was excellent," highlighting the promptness and efficiency of the service.
• Reviewers found the restaurant "absolutely phenomenal" with "incredible" food, indicating high levels of satisfaction.
• A recommendation for a "great scratch-cooked meal" reflects the authenticity and quality of the food.
• The portion sizes were appreciated, with one review noting, "You get a ton of food," implying great value for money.

Atmosphere and Service

• Praise for attentive staff, with specific mentions: "Victor did a great job telling us about the history" and "Amanda was probably the best waitress we've ever had."
• An "old time feel" complemented by watching ducks swimming around adds to a unique dining experience.
• The restaurant's setup provides a "view of the river," enhancing the dining atmosphere.
• Reviewers noted that despite busy periods, wait times were often shorter than expected, improving the overall experience.

Food Quality

• The "corn chowder was amazing," with a unique twist involving peppers or pimentos.
• Meals such as the "chicken fried steak with mashed potatoes and green beans" and "Pot Roast with green beans" were highlighted as perfectly prepared.
• Signature dishes like the "Chicken Pot Pie" were described as having a "tender flaky crust," indicating skillful preparation.
• The availability of family-style sides and desserts like pie or homemade ice cream was a noted highlight of the menu.

Overall Experience

• Many customers "highly recommend this place" and expressed intentions to return, indicating strong overall satisfaction.
• A suggestion for visiting "with an empty stomach" emphasizes the generous portion sizes and meal offerings.
• The setting and quality of service ensure the experience is "worth the wait," even during busy times.
• Combining delicious food, excellent service, and a charming atmosphere, reviewers felt the restaurant stood out in a "rather commercial" area.