Matunuck Oyster Bar 🦪

What People Are Saying 💬

AI summary of real reviews

Customer Praise

• "The food was truly spectacular" with standout dishes like the "tomato and buratta salad, fresh and fried oysters, clams casino, tuna, scallop, and steak dinners."
• Described as "one of the best restaurants in the area," with a high level of admiration for the cuisine.
• Seafood dishes such as "beautifully prepared salmon with a sweet and spicy ginger glaze" and the "lobster avocado roll with a mango twist" received high praise.
• "The New York cheesecake is one of the best cheesecakes I have ever tried in my life," highlighting exceptional dessert options.

Atmosphere and Service

• One reviewer experienced challenges with reservations, noting they "were told we could sit on the roof without shade or on a tour boat" despite booking in advance.
• An overall positive atmosphere experienced by another guest who enjoyed "a wonderful birthday dinner relaxing on the patio."
• Some reviews highlighted service issues such as "it took 20 minutes to get warm tap water" and "dinner arrived in the middle of our appetizers."
• "The front of the house manager even had to take a large stack of dirty plates" indicating a lapse in service coordination.

Food Quality

• Rave reviews for seafood dishes like "fresh oysters that are delicate yet have a hint of brine" and "crisp calamari."
• "Main courses were cooked to perfection," underscoring the expertise in meal preparation.
• "Everything on the menu is delicious," with a particular nod to freshness, especially in seafood.
• Dessert options stand out, particularly the "rich and amazing" dessert that complemented the meal experience.

Overall Experience

• One guest was torn, giving a "3 stars because the food was truly spectacular" despite service issues at a high price point.
• Another visitor expresses enthusiasm with "Matunuck Oyster Bar is FIVE stars across the board" and urges others to "make a reservation ahead of time."
• Some guests experienced significant wait times, such as "a total of 45 minutes before we ate anything."
• The sentiment, "The best of the best! I wish I lived closer so I could come more often!" perfectly encapsulates repeat visits despite service inconsistencies.