The Frog & The Peach 🐸🍑

What People Are Saying 💬

AI summary of real reviews

Customer Praise

• "Everything was excellent, except…the food" – but overall, the experience was praised.
• The reviewer expressed intent to return: "Absolutely would return" for another dining experience.
• The restaurant was described as "a staple in New Brunswick" with elegance and ambiance.
• Customers appreciated the "nice dinner" and expressed readiness to get used to dining out at such places.

Atmosphere and Service

• The atmosphere was described as "excellent" with the potential for events, such as "the Florida room looked perfect to throw a shower of some sort."
• The service was characterized as "impeccable," with the right balance of attention and a welcoming staff.
• One review highlighted the knowledgeable waiter who provided useful recommendations and thoroughly explained the chef’s specials.
• Critique included the lack of a warm greeting on a special day, contrasting expectations for special occasions.

Food Quality

• The food opinions varied, with some appetizers, like the "truffle gnocchi," praised for their taste despite not being served at the right temperature.
• There was disappointment with some entrees, such as the ribeye, which lacked flavor and salt.
• Additions like the peach component in the tasting menu were memorable despite being a bit overwhelming by the end.
• Dishes like lamb, steak with butternut squash tamale, and halibut were described as made with pride, appealing to foodies' imaginations.

Overall Experience

• Most reviewers will return, indicating a generally positive overall experience, despite some food reservations.
• Special mentions include the restaurant's potential for other dining experiences, though there is some critique that it "didn’t live up to the 'experience' advertised" for special occasions.
• The cost was noted, with some questioning if the tasting menu and wine pairing justified the high price.
• Aspects such as valet service are recommended and contribute positively to the overall experience.