Tony's 🍽️

What People Are Saying 💬

AI summary of real reviews

Customer Praise

• "Absolute culinary gem" - guests consistently find the restaurant .a standout in the city's dining scene.
• Long-standing patrons consider it the "best Italian" in town, even within a competitive market.
• The restaurant holds a special place for customers' anniversaries and other memorable events.
• "Highly recommended" by multiple reviewers who praise both food and service.

Atmosphere and Service

• Mixed reviews on the ambiance; some describe it as "warm and inviting," while others find the setting less welcoming due to seating issues.
• "Service is impeccable," with attentive staff and knowledgeable about the menu.
• Guests appreciate thoughtful touches, like exchanging water for a fresh one by the end of the meal.
• Table service details include platting, resetting service, and crumb collection, though some reviewers mention feelings of inconsistency in attention.

Food Quality

• Reviewers praise culinary offerings as "nothing short of extraordinary," with a diverse selection of dishes showcasing chefs' expertise.
• Special mentions for the Ahi Tuna Tartare (though spicy), Scallops, and Penne with Asparagus and Wild Mushrooms.
• Deserts, particularly the "whipped cheesecake," receive strong recommendations not to be skipped.
• Mixed reviews on mussels ("gritty" with shell bits), pointing out inconsistency in food quality.

Overall Experience

• "Unforgettable dining experience" leaving guests eager to return, recommended for both special occasions and casual nights out.
• Some patrons note excellent cocktail preparation and specific dishes, like Linguine with Lobster and Shrimp, as the "best pasta" they’ve had.
• Unique experiences like kitchen tours are offered, although opinions on this are divided, with some viewing it as unprofessional.
• Concerns about furniture placement leading to discomfort; narrow aisles causing frequent chair bumps for some diners, affecting the experience.