Nicola Pizza 🍕

What People Are Saying 💬

AI summary of real reviews

Customer Praise

• "The pizza sauce and dough is so fresh and the Nicaboli’s are great!"
• "Best fresh salads around town."
• "Nicola Pizza offers a variety of traditional entrees but... excels more in their quick pizza and Boli's."
• "The food was very good. The pizza was a good value. It came out fast and hot."
• "The cheese fries were amazing. The cheese sauce was this amazing mix that we licked the plate clean."
• "The Original Nic-o-Boli may be one of the most perfect foods ever invented."

Atmosphere and Service

• "The building is big and beautiful with plenty of space and seemingly no wait time with many nostalgic mementos of the old original pizzeria!"
• "The place was very loud. Like a school cafeteria."
• "When dining in, expect food to come out individually and not all at the same time."
• "With the amount of families visiting the inside seating area can get pretty loud... I would recommend sitting outside (weather permitting) if you're not a fan of loud noises."
• "A plus was the free drink refills which we took to go since we were heading to the Cape May-Lewes Ferry!"

Food Quality

• "The pizza sauce and dough is so fresh."
• "The Red Devil sauce was reminiscent of Franks red hot."
• "Nicola’s excels in their soft but yet not too soft crust and their house-made sauce is an old-time staple that's a little sweet."
• "The food was very good. The pizza was a good value. It came out fast and hot."
• "The cheese fries were amazing. The cheese sauce was this amazing mix that we licked the plate clean."
• "The boli was full of meat, but it was just smaller than we thought it would be."
• "The Original Nic-o-Boli may be one of the most perfect foods ever invented."

Overall Experience

• "Recommended for families with kids or those looking for a quick bite of traditional pizza."
• "While they do have a take-out window, when dining in expect food to come out individually and not all at the same time."
• "The waitress was a bit on the dry side and we were seated by the bathroom."
• "Overall I probably will go back and recommend it as well but... I was just short of disappointed!"
• "When ordering a Boli, they come out very hot!"
• "It would have been nice to have some sort of measurements or ideas of size for the first-time customer."