Sims Corner Steakhouse & Oyster Bar 🥩

What People Are Saying 💬

AI summary of real reviews

Customer Praise

• "One word, amazing!!" describes the delight with the cozy ambiance and stellar food. "Thanks for the wonderful evening and experience."
• Remarkable fresh local oysters were a highlight: "You can’t beat local oysters, seriously, these little babies are sold all over the place."
• A customer praised the restaurant for its unique offering of fresh whole lobster from the island for lunch.
• The sirloin pepper steak and fresh oysters were particularly memorable: "Their sirloin pepper steak was on point and cooked to perfection."

Atmosphere and Service

• The restaurant was described as "a cozy little spot," perfect for a travel visit to the island.
• Though there was a delay with the reservation and seating, it was noted as "just a bad night" and not typical of the establishment.
• Exceptional service was noted: "Thank you to Francis for being an exceptional host. Very attentive and knowledgeable."
• Another diner praised the service: "We were served by a wonderful and professional waitress girl."

Food Quality

• Oysters were a standout, both freshly chucked and broiled, described as "delectable" and "wonderful."
• Appetizers were highly praised: "The appetizers were amazing," and the Caesar salad was lauded as "the best that I’ve had in a while."
• The tenderloin was rated "10/10," although there was a suggestion to use higher-quality vegetables than zucchini.
• The ribeye and filet mignon with Gouda crust came highly recommended, along with the seafood chowder which was "good with a lot of seafood."

Overall Experience

• One customer had a fantastic experience: "It was a pleasure dining at Sims and we’ll definitely be back."
• Despite a delay with the reservation and food, another reviewer still appreciated the overall quality of the establishment, mentioning it was "not a bad place, just a bad night."
• High quality of food and drink were reiterated: "Drinks, food and service were of the highest quality."
• The mix of great seafood dishes, such as the Seafood Fettuccine and local oysters, added to a positive dining experience.